Category expertise for contingent workforce, agency and payroll sourcing.
Contractor and IR35 Risk: How to Bring It Under Control
To reduce contractor and IR35 risk, you need clear visibility of who you engage, how each status decision is made and which suppliers sit in the chain. SmartBuyer match you with one of 500+ vetted procurement specialists within 48 hours, including contingent workforce experts who help you build governance, control rates and consolidate agencies.

Why is contractor risk rising for UK organisations?
Since the off-payroll working rules were extended to the private sector, medium and large clients have been responsible for deciding each contractor’s IR35 status. From 6 April 2026, the size thresholds used for the rules increased, so a company is now treated as small only if it meets two of three tests: turnover up to £15m, a balance sheet up to £7.5m and no more than 50 employees.
Group figures are combined across connected entities, and a business that stops being small must tell its contractors that responsibility has passed to it. Growth, acquisitions and group structure can all change who carries the risk.
What’s at risk if nothing changes?
If status decisions are wrong or poorly documented, HMRC can recover unpaid tax and National Insurance, with interest and penalties, and the liability can move up the supply chain to the client. Blanket decisions applied to whole groups of contractors are especially hard to defend.
Weak contractor governance also costs money in less visible ways. Multiple agencies supplying similar roles at different rates, extensions agreed without review and contractors engaged outside approved routes all push up spend and make the risk harder to see.
Unclear status decisions and incomplete records make risk difficult to assess.
Inconsistent rates and extensions can increase costs without visibility.
What should you do first?
Build a single picture of your contingent workforce. List every contractor, the agency or intermediary involved, the role, the day rate, the start date and the status determination statement issued. Gaps in this list are usually where the biggest risks sit.
Next, confirm whether your organisation is in scope under the current thresholds, check how status decisions are made and recorded, and review long-running engagements first. Involve your legal, tax and HR colleagues early, as they will need to approve any changes to policy or process.
Map the workforce
Identify contractors, agencies, roles, rates and engagement dates.
Review status records
Check the process and documentation behind determinations.
Align stakeholders
Bring procurement, legal, tax and HR into the same process.
How SmartBuyer help with contractor and IR35 risk
We match you with a contingent workforce specialist who has improved governance in organisations like yours. They map your contractor and agency estate, review how status determinations are made and documented, benchmark rates and consolidate suppliers into a controlled preferred supplier list, MSP or VMS arrangement.
Specialists work alongside your legal and tax advisers rather than replacing them. Their role is the commercial and process side: clear accountability, fewer suppliers, consistent rates and an audit trail that stands up to scrutiny.
Results: contingent workforce programmes delivered
Specialists in the SmartBuyer network have led global recruitment process outsourcing sourcing for a bioscience company with £140m in annual contingent labour spend, and negotiated a £30m payroll outsourcing deal covering 110,000 employees.
Frequently asked questions
Is our organisation responsible for IR35 decisions?
If your organisation is medium or large and engages contractors through their own limited companies, you are usually responsible for deciding their status and issuing a status determination statement. Small companies are exempt, so check the current thresholds against your group’s figures each year.
Can SmartBuyer give legal advice on IR35?
No. SmartBuyer specialists focus on procurement, governance and supplier management, and work alongside your legal and tax advisers, who remain responsible for legal judgements. Specialists help you build the process, documentation and supplier controls that make those judgements consistent and defensible.
How is IR35 handled for SmartBuyer’s own specialists?
IR35 is managed as part of every SmartBuyer engagement, so bringing in one of our specialists does not add to your contractor risk. We assess each engagement against the off-payroll working rules with you and keep a clear written record for your legal, HR and finance teams to review.
We already have an MSP or VMS. Do we still need help?
Often, yes. An MSP or VMS gives you a platform and a process, but it does not guarantee the rates, supplier mix or status decisions flowing through it are right. A specialist can review how well the programme is working, close gaps and help you get more value from the system you already pay for.
Related services and resources
Get your contractor risk under control
Tell us how many contractors you engage, which agencies you use and where you see the biggest risk. We will introduce a matched contingent workforce specialist within 48 hours. Book a call to get started.